After an overdose of reality television from the earthly realm, Santa comes up with a plan to secure his son a wife. If it worked for those on the vision box, surely, it would help his son.
Sending out his elf force to find a group of suitable women, they return with an extensive list of candidates. Santa sends out ten invitations to women, who as children were always on the good list, and invites them to the North Pole.
Unbeknownst to his hard-working son Sander, Santa puts his plan into motion. By the time Sander discovers what his father's up to, Elf Time Visions has already started production, and the ten women had moved into Santa's Village.
The last thing Sander had time for, even in the off season, was a silly show for the vision box. One thing troubled him, even after enduring dates with the different women, two of them stood out. Sander had to decide if his father's crazy plan might end up being the best thing for him, if he could decide between who was naughty and who was nice.