In the tiny town of Plainville, Jared Whitehead grew up in church and is now trying to live out his faith like a man. Influenced first by a fiery preacher who crashes in a moral scandal, then by a godly pastor who challenges his long-held convictions, Jared is forced to come to terms with what he really believes about God. But when tragedy strikes his family, his faith in his sovereign God faces the test of his lifetime.