Anna Hershberger has vowed never to date an Englischer again after a bad experience a year ago. But when a visiting teacher comes into town, he woos everyone with his polish and charm. Still hurting from her betrayal, she resists his advances because she doesn't want to go through the same heartache again, especially with an Englischer. But will he be able to break down her defenses and make her see the good man he truly is?