It has been a year since the Wears Valley massacre and the Final Eleven (dubbed as such by the media), attempt to return to normalcy; however, for Theo Rose, nothing is the same. After his first session with his new therapist, Dr. Dolores Stranton, he receives a call from his estranged friend, Selena Price, informing him of Mama's return and that...
"Mercy's alive!" Theo dismisses her claim and assumes that she is seeing things, refusing to believe anyone could survive such a fall. But when Selena vanishes, Theo becomes worried that perhaps she is telling the truth and the Adams have returned. Are the Final Eleven able to survive a second massacre, or will they have the courage to end this nightmare?