Charlie Miller moved to Montana to help her friend Merry, and she did so happily, knowing there were more men than women in the west. She expected to meet someone and live happily ever after. When she's still alone three years later, she seriously contemplates writing to her sister Elizabeth, hoping she'll find a husband for her. A chance meeting with a stranger in a snowstorm changes all her plans.
Abel Burton takes a chance and heads to Mistletoe, Montana, to meet a local artist. Meeting Charlie is just a side benefit—one that will change him forever. When he returns home, he takes his new bride with him. He worries that his sister-in-law will get in the way of his happiness when she immediately treats Charlie as her servant. Will the two of them get past the interference caused by the other woman's presence? Or will they lose their chance for true love?